Now hiring shiny, Rusty people. Great pay, sweet perks, safe environment. Apply Now!

Worthington Menu

Monday - Saturday: 11 a.m. - 10 p.m. 
Sunday: 11 a.m. - 9 p.m.

Menu pricing and items subject to change

 

Make Reservation or Order Online Now
Gary's Favorites

To take the edge off... or make the kids happy!

  • Salted Edamame
    $5.00
    BBQ Pork Rinds
    $4.00
    Slider
    $3.00

  • Pierogi
    cheese & potato dumpling, polish kraut, garlic cream, bacon butter $10.49
    Double Stacked Quesadilla
    blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa $12.79
    Rusty Bucket Wings
    Tommy want wingy
    Joe’s Regular, BBQ or Habanero, blue cheese, celery $13.99
    Spinach Con Queso
    Next step is to fold in the cheese
    liquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips $10.29
    Fried Pickles
    pilsner-battered spears, cilantro ranch $9.99
    Brussels Sprouts
    parmesan, lemon aioli $10.99
    Buffalo Cauliflower
    roasted, toasted panko, blue cheese, celery $10.99
    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    chilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce $12.49
    Chicken Fingers
    pilsner-battered, crispy fries $13.49
    "Cheese Blanket" Nachos
    Sweet Dreams are made of Cheese
    most of the dairy section with chips, pico, black beans, jalapeños, sour cream, scallions
    add chicken 3| add ground beef 4

    *available for dine-in only  $12.99 | add chicken 3 or ground beef 4

  • Crock of Soup
    sirloin chili | french onion | soup du jour  $6.29
    Duo
    choice of side salad & cup of soup $11.29
    Trio
    choice of side salad, cup of soup & ½ club sandwich $13.29
    Double Nickel Salad
    mixed greens topped with our special dressing, bacon, tomato, onion, blue cheese crumbles, house dressing $6.99 | add chicken 6 or salmon 9
    Simple
    Our New Normal 
    carrot, cucumber, tomato, sharp cheddar, crouton, choice of dressing $6.99 | add chicken 6 or salmon 9
    Greek
    Fresher than John Stamos
    mixed greens, cured vegetables, pickled onion, marinated tomato, kalamata olive, pepperoncini, chickpea, feta, greek vinaigrette $7.99 | add chicken 6 or salmon 9
    Blackened Salmon
    shaved fennel and brussels sprouts, baby gem, kale, strawberries, avocado, goat cheese, candied pistachio, honey vinaigrette $15.99
    Cobb
    roma crunch, bacon, avocado, egg, cucumber, grape tomato, blue cheese, herbed chicken, red wine vinaigrette  $14.29
    BBQ Chopped
    Chop it like it's hot
    BBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa, tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch  $13.29

Just for Kiddos (10 & Under)
Includes one side and choice of drink

  • Kids Sliders
    ....with or without cheese $6.29
    Kids Soft Tacos
    ...taco meat, lettuce, cheese  $6.99
    Kids French Bread Pizza
    ...pep or cheese  $6.99
    Kids Fish n Chips
    ...Fish and Fries (Duh) $6.49
    Kids Chicken Fingers
    ...BBQ or honey mustard  $6.49
    Kids Spaghetti & Meatball
    ...with garlic bread  $6.99
    Kids Mac n Cheese
    ...seriously? we need to explain?  $5.99
    Kids Sides
    French fries
    mashed potatoes
    sticky rice
    broccolini
    fresh fruit cup
    cole slaw
     
    Kids Cast Iron Brownie
    $5.99
    Kids Oreo Snowball
    $4.99
    Kids Trip to Disneyland
    ...priceless

  • Baja Fish Tacos
    blackened mahi, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime crema, Mexican street corn salad $15.99
    Fish 'n Chips
    pilsner-battered cold water cod, seasoned fries $16.99
    New York Strip
    brussels sprouts, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi $22.99
    Ma, The Meatloaf!
    Ma! We want it now!
    French green beans, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi $15.49
    Soy Glazed Salmon
    sticky rice, stir-fried beans $19.49
    Chicken Parm
    you taste so good! panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles $15.99

Served with kettle chips, cole slaw, or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries or mac & cheese for an additional $1.59
Whole wheat bun available upon request

  • Bucket
    The O.G.
    American cheese, MR. PLOT $13.29
    The Imposter
    plant-based patty, American cheese, MR.PLOT
    make it vegan and dump the dairy (request no mayo or cheese) $13.29
    Turkey
    Bucket Burger's side hustle.
    American cheese, mayo, pickle, LTO $12.49
    Bacon
    bacon-infused, cheddar, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli $14.49

Served with kettle chips, cole slaw, or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries or mac & cheese for an additional $1.59
Whole wheat bun available upon request

  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
    panko-crusted, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato, mayo $13.49
    El Cubano
    Try and sneak this through customs
    tavern ham, braised pork, house mustard, pickles $13.99
    Hoosier Daddy Pork Tenderloin
    No chair throwing please!
    ​breaded and fried, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, side mayo $12.99
    Reuben
    slow-braised corned beef brisket, swiss, thousand, kraut, artisan rye $13.79
    Cheesesteak
    peppers, onion, mushroom, provolone, Philly sauce $13.29
    Club
    turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat $12.99
    Codwich
    panko-crusted, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar $12.99

  • Vegan Fried Rice Bowl
    cauliflower rice, peppers, kimchi, corn, bean sprouts, carrots, broccolini, soy
    rebel against the establishment, add sunny-side up egg * $14.49
    Chicky Chicky Bowl
    herbed chicken, kale, farro, pickled carrots, curried cauliflower, marinated tomato & beets, pine nuts, goat cheese $15.99
    NEW!
    Poke Bowl
    You Can Tune a Piano, But You Can’t Tuna Fish
    yellow fin tuna, cucumber, pickled carrot, toasted sesame seed, nori, wasabi mayo, sriracha $16.99
    Baked Rigatoni
    crushed meatballs, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil $15.49
    Beef Stroganoff
    pot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream $15.49

We've been rolling them by hand since college

  • Margherita
    roasted tomato, garlic, fresh mozzarella, basil $13.79
    Pepperoni and Peppers
    ezzo pepperoni & Hungarian peppers, das it $13.99
    Veggie
    spinach, wild mushroom, roasted tomato, peppers, onion, green olive $13.49
    Wild Mushroom
    Super Mario's favorite
    roasted garlic, shiitake, portabella, caramelized onion, spinach, truffle oil $15.49
    Sicilian
    italian sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, tavern ham, peppers, caramelized onion $15.49
    Cheese
    provolone, whole milk mozzarella $12.99
    Toppings
    Meat: Ezzo pepperoni, sausage, chicken, bacon, tavern ham - $1.99

    Veg: jalapeño, peppers, spinach, roasted tomato, onion, wild mushroom, green olive ​- $1.45

  • Sidekicks
    broccolini 3.99
    sweet potato fries 3.99
    mashed potatoes 3.99
    fruit cup 3.99
    onion rings 3.99
    mac & cheese 4.99
    Mexican street corn salad 4.99
    cole slaw 3.99

  • Sticky Bun Bread Pudding
    baked croissants and vanilla custard, caramel, pecans, Edy’s vanilla bean ice cream $6.99
    New York Cheesecake
    macerated strawberry, whipped cream
    and bonus, it’s gluten-free friendly! $6.99
    Dessert Feature
    ask your server about our featured selection created by our chef team!!!
    Cast Iron Brownie
    vanilla bean ice cream, caramel, powdered sugar $6.29

Brunch without booze is just a sad, late breakfast
Saturday & Sunday | 11am-3pm

  • Chicken and Waffles
    no description needed $11.79
    NEW!
    Honey Buns
    baked to order, vanilla caramel glaze, pecans...and I think I tasted egg and cinnamon $9.99
    Breakfast Burrito
    flour tortilla stuffed with scrambled eggs, sausage, sautéed peppers & onions, pepper jack & cheddar cheese. topped with ranchero sauce, sour cream and cilantro.
    served with red skin breakfast potatoes  $12.39
    NEW!
    Denver Omelet
    tavern ham, bell pepper, onion, cheddar jack, breakfast potato, wheat toast $12.99
    Short Rib Hash
    crispy potatoes, peppers, caramelized onion, sharp cheddar, sunny side eggs $12.99
    NEW!
    Triple Decker Breakfast Sammich
    wheat, swiss, American, cheddar, tavern ham, 2 eggs, tomato, scallion, garlic aioli $10.99

  • Lemonade or Iced Tea
    craft your own.

    add smashed blueberries, blackberries, raspberry or strawberry puree $3.99
    Strawberry Cooler
    $4.99
    Housemade Cold Brew Coffee
    $3.99
    San Pellegrino
    $3.49

  • Daily Drink Features
    Monday Burger 'N Beer
    Juicy Lucy Burger and a Pint for $10

    Poppin’ bottles Tuesday
    1/2 priced bottles of wine

    Whiskey Wednesday
    Woodford, Old Forester, Jack & the others

    Punch Perfect Thursday
    our house draft punch: I’m with friends pitcher or I’m solo

    Shaken not stirred Friday
    Belvedere martini, pine fin cosmo, pine fin martini

    Gary’s Famous Margarita Saturday
    share a pitcher (or drink one yourself)

    Bloody Sunday
    pepper-infused Finlandia Vodka, house-spiced pickle

  • Blueberry Bella
    Smirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice $8.00
    Pine Fin
    your choice: rocks, martini or cosmo $8.25
    Draft Margarita
    El Jimador, Cointreau, fresh lemon and lime $9.25 add a bucket of Herradura, El Jimador, or Grand Marnier for 5
    Draft Bucket Punch
    Mount Gay Rum, pine fin, Cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum $8.75
    Bloody Mary
    pepper-soaked Finlandia Vodka

    Not Spicy - green, red and Hungarian pepper
    Spicy - jalapeno pepper and lime
    Stupid Spicy - habanero, green and red pepper $8.75
    Sangria
    ginger citrus white or orange pomegranate red $7.00
    NEW!
    Sun Comes Up In Mexico
    Cazadores resposado, cointreau, orange, lime, agave nectar, house grenadine  $10.00
    NEW!
    Put Me In Coach
    Old Forester, apricot liqueur, lemon, ginger syrup $10.00
    NEW!
    Wake Up Juice
    Cold Brew, Wheatley Vodka, espresso vodka, Cantera Negra Cafe' $9.00
    NEW!
    Gettin Spritzy Wit It
    Aperol, prosecco, hummingbird bitters, lemon, orange $10.00

  • Brown Bag Special
    12oz $2.50
    Bell's Two Hearted IPA
    Comstock, MI $5.99
    Brewdog Elvis Juice
    Columbus, OH $5.99
    Brew Dog Hazy Jane
    $5.79
    Budweiser
    St Louis, MO $3.99
    Bud Light
    St Louis, MO $3.99
    CBC Bodhi
    Columbus, OH 46.49
    Coors Lite
    Denver, CO $3.99
    Corona
    Mexico city, Mexico $5.79
    Dos XX
    $4.99
    Downeast Cider
    $5.99
    Fat Tire
    Fort Collins, CO $5.79
    Michelob Ultra
    $4.49
    Miller Lite
    Milwaukee, WI $3.99
    North High Honey Wheat
    $5.79
    Rhinegeist Truth
    Cincinnati, OH $5.99
    Seventh Son Selection
    Columbus, OH $5.99
    White Claw
    Chicago, IL $5.99
    Truly
    $5.99

  • Bud Light
    St Louis, MO 16oz $4.79 | 20oz $5.79
    Miller Lite
    Milwaukee, WI 16oz $4.79 | 20oz $5.79
    Blue Moon
    Golden, CO 16oz $5.99 | 20oz $6.99
    Sam Adams Selection
    Boston, MA 16oz $6.79 | 20oz $7.79
    New Belgium Selection
    Fort Collins, CO 16oz $6.79 | 20oz $7.79
    North High Rusty Bucket Jeffrey Pilsner
    16oz $6.79 | 20oz $7.79
    Rhinegeist Selection
    Cincinnati, OH 16oz $6.99 | 20oz $7.99
    Guinness
    Dublin, Ireland 16oz $6.79 | 20oz $7.79
    Stella Artois
    Leuven, Belgium 16oz $6.79 | 20oz $7.79

Because...The Catalina Wine Mixer

  • Moscato, Seven Daughters
    6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00
    White Zinfandel, Beringer
    6oz $6.25 | 9oz $8.25 | Bottle $25.00
    Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00
    Pinot Grigio, Campanile
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00
    Sauvignon Blanc, Honig
    6oz $9.50 | 9oz $12.00 | Bottle $38.00
    Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek
    6oz $6.95 | 9oz $9.75 | Bottle $28.00
    Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”
    6oz $8.25 | 9oz $10.75 | Bottle $33.00
    Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”
    6oz $11.75 | 9oz $15.00 | Bottle $47.00

  • Pinot Noir, Hangtime
    6oz $9.75 | 9oz $12.75 | Bottle $39.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Glass Mountain
    6oz $6.95 | 9oz $9.75 | Bottle $28.00
    Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios
    6oz $10.25 | 9oz $13.75 | Bottle $41.00
    Merlot, Benziger
    6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00
    Merlot, Red Diamond Winery
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”
    6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Spellbound
    6oz $9.75 | 9oz $12.75 | Bottle $39.00
    Red Blend, The Federalist
    *available by the bottle only $52.00

  • Prosecco
    Brut, Zonin, “Special Cuvee” 6oz $9.25 | 9oz $11.75 | Bottle $37.00
    Rosé
    M. Chapoutier, “Belleruche” 6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00

Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your group has a food allergy or special dietary need (e.g. gluten intolerance). While we will do our best to accommodate your needs, please be aware our restaurant uses ingredients that contain all the major FDA allergens (peanuts, tree nuts, eggs, fish, shellfish, milk, soy & wheat). We offer gluten-free friendly menus; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free.

  • Gluten Free Double Stacked Quesadilla
    blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean, corn salsa & corn tortilla $11.99
    Gluten Free Peel & Eat Shrimp
    chilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce $11.99
    Gluten Free Double Nickel Salad
    bacon, tomato, onion, house dressing $6.79
    NEW!
    Gluten Free Blackened Salmon
    shaved fennel and brussels sprouts, kale, greens,strawberry, avocado, shishito pepper, pistachio, goat cheese vinaigrette  $15.99
    Gluten Free Baja Fish Tacos
    blackened fish, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime cream, corn tortilla $15.99
    Gluten Free New York Strip
    mashed potatoes, wild mushroom, french green beans $22.99
    Gluten Free Pan Seared Salmon
    garlic and herb glazed, mashed potatoes, green beans $20.49
    Gluten Free Chicky Chicky Bowl
    herbed chicken, kale, pickled carrots, curried cauliflower, pine nuts, goat cheese, marinated tomato & beets $15.99
    Gluten Free Baked Penne
    gluten-free penne, Italian sausage, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil $15.49
    Gluten Free Bucket Burger
    American cheese, MR. PLOT $14.49
    Gluten Free Turkey Burger
    American cheese, mayo, pickle LTO $11.79
    Gluten Free Bacon Burger
    bacon-infused, cheddar, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli $13.29
    Gluten Free Sidekicks
    Broccolini - $4.29
    Mashed Potatoes - $4.29
    Cole Slaw - $4.29
    French Green Beans - $3.89
    Fruit Cup - $3.89

  • Double Stacked Quesadilla
    blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa $57.99, Serves 8-10
    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    chilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce $57.99, Serves 8-10
    Brussels Sprouts
    parmesan, lemon aioli $44.99, Serves 8-10
    Wings
    Tommy want wingy
    sauces: Joe’s regular, BBQ or habanero. Served with celery & blue cheese  $61.99, Serves 8-10
    Sliders
    carmelized onion, American cheese, pickle
      $52.99, Serves 8-10
    Spinach Con Queso
    Next step is to fold in the cheese
    liquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips $42.99, Serves 8-10
    NEW!
    Simple Salad
    carrot, cucumber, tomato, sharp cheddar, crouton, choice of dressing $29.99 | add chicken $62.99, Serves 6-8
    Double Nickel Salad
    mixed greens topped with our special dressing, chopped bacon, blue cheese crumbles, tomatoes and red onion $29.99 | add chicken $62.99, Serves 6-8
    BBQ Chopped Salad
    BBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa,tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch 
      $62.99, Serves 6-8
    NEW!
    Greek Salad
    mixed greens, cured vegetables, pickled onion, marinated tomato, kalamata olive, pepperoncini, chick pea, feta, greek vinaigrette $36.99 | add chicken $69.99, Serves 6-8
    Baked Rigatoni
    crushed meatballs, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil $67.99, Serves 6-8
    Chicken Parm
    you taste so good! panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles $67.99, Serves 6-8
    Beef Stroganoff
    pot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream $67.99, Serves 6-8
    Club
    turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat $51.99, Serves 8-10
    Catering Sides
    Cole Slaw - $24.99
    Fruit Salad- $32.99
    Broccolini - $29.99
    Pasta Salad - $29.99
    Mashed Potatoes - $26.99
    French Green Beans - $29.99
    Kettle Chips - $10.99
    Mac & Cheese - $29.99

      Serves 8-10

  • Blueberry Bella
    Smirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice $8.00
    Pine Fin
    your choice: rocks, martini or cosmo $8.25
    Draft Margarita
    El Jimador, Cointreau, fresh lemon and lime $9.25 add a bucket of Herradura, El Jimador, or Grand Marnier for 5
    Draft Bucket Punch
    Mount Gay Rum, pine fin, Cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum $8.75
    Sangria
    ginger citrus white or orange pomegranate red $7.00
    Bloody Mary
    pepper-soaked Finlandia Vodka

    Not Spicy - green, red and Hungarian pepper
    Spicy - jalapeno pepper and lime
    Stupid Spicy - habanero, green and red pepper $8.75
    NEW!
    Sun Comes Up In Mexico
    Cazadores resposado, cointreau, orange, lime, agave nectar, house grenadine  $10.00
    NEW!
    Put Me In Coach
    Old Forester, apricot liqueur, lemon, ginger syrup $10.00
    NEW!
    Wake Up Juice
    Cold Brew, Wheatley Vodka, espresso vodka, Cantera Negra Cafe' $9.00
    NEW!
    Gettin Spritzy Wit It
    Aperol, prosecco, hummingbird bitters, lemon, orange $10.00

  • Bud Light
    St Louis, MO $9.00
    Coors Lite
    Denver, CO $9.00
    Miller Lite
    Milwaukee, WI $9.00
    Brewdog Elvis Juice
    Columbus, OH $11.00
    CBC Bodhi
    Columbus, OH $13.00
    North High Honey Wheat
    $11.00
    Rhinegeist Truth
    Cincinnati, OH $11.00
    Seventh Son Humulus Nimbus
    Columbus, OH $11.00
    White Claw
    Chicago, IL $10.00

  • Moscato, Seven Daughters
    $16.00
    White Zinfandel, Beringer
    $11.00
    Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle
    $12.00
    Pinot Grigio, Campanile
    $12.00
    Sauvignon Blanc, Honig
    $19.00
    Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek
    $11.00
    Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”
    $11.00
    Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”
    $27.00
    Prosecco
    Brut, Zonin, “Special Cuvee” $21.00
    Rosé
    M. Chapoutier, “Belleruche” $19.00

  • Pinot Noir, Hangtime
    $14.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Glass Mountain
    $13.00
    Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios
    $17.00
    Merlot, Benziger
    $24.00
    Merlot, Red Diamond Winery
    $11.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”
    $14.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Spellbound
    $18.00

* Consuming raw or undercooked meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Please inform your server of any food allergies.

** We offer gluten-free friendly options; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free