Now hiring shiny, Rusty people. Great pay, sweet perks, safe environment. Apply Now!
Worthington Menu
Monday: 11 a.m. - 9 p.m.
Tuesday - Saturday: 11 a.m. - 10 p.m.
Sunday: 11 a.m. - 9 p.m.
Menu pricing and items subject to change
Gary's Favorites
To take the edge off... or make the kids happy!
-
Salted Edamame$5.00Shishito Peppers$5.00BBQ Pork Rinds$4.00Slider$3.00
-
Pierogicheese & potato dumpling, polish kraut, garlic cream, bacon butter $9.99Double Stacked Quesadillablackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa $11.99Rusty Bucket WingsJoe’s Regular, BBQ or Habanero, blue cheese, celery $12.99Spinach Con Quesoliquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips $10.29Fried Picklespilsner-battered spears, cilantro ranch $8.99Brussels Sproutsparmesan, lemon aioli $9.99Buffalo Cauliflowerroasted, toasted panko, blue cheese, celery $10.49Peel & Eat Shrimpchilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce $11.49Chicken Fingerspilsner-battered, crispy fries $12.49"Cheese Blanket" NachosTake comfort in the fact that we lose money every time we sell one of these! super cheesy!!! braised black beans, jalapeños and scallions; served with pico de gallo and sour cream. add chicken add beef $12.99 | add chicken 3 or ground beef 4
-
Crock of Soupsirloin chili | french onion | soup du jour $6.19Duochoice of side salad & cup of soup $10.99Triochoice of side salad, cup of soup & ½ club sandwich $12.99Double Nickel Saladmixed greens topped with our special dressing, bacon, tomato, onion, blue cheese crumbles, house dressing $6.79 | add chicken 6 or salmon 8NEW!SimpleOur New Normal
carrot, cucumber, tomato, sharp cheddar, crouton, choice of dressing $6.79 | add chicken 6 or salmon 8NEW!Greekmixed greens, cured vegetables, pickled onion, marinated tomato, kalamata olive, pepperoncini, chickpea, feta, greek vinaigrette $7.99 | add chicken 6 or salmon 8NEW!Blackened SalmonWho Says We Can’t Improve on a Great Thing?
shaved fennel and brussels sprouts, kale, greens, strawberry, avocado, shishito pepper, pistachio, goat cheese vinaigrette $15.29NEW!Green Goddessherbed chicken, shaved brussels sprouts, baby gem, kale, marinated tomato, shishito pepper, crouton, parmesan, green goddess dressing $13.99NEW!Cobbroma crunch, bacon, avocado, egg, cucumber, grape tomato, blue cheese, herbed chicken, red wine vinaigrette $14.29BBQ ChoppedBBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa, tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch $12.79
Just for Kiddos (10 & Under)
Includes one side and choice of drink
-
Kids Sliders....with or without cheese $5.99Kids Soft Tacos...taco meat, lettuce, cheese $6.99Kids French Bread Pizza...pep or cheese $6.99Kids Fish n Chips...Fish and Fries (Duh) $6.29Kids Chicken Fingers...BBQ or honey mustard $5.99Kids Spaghetti & Meatball...with garlic bread $6.99Kids Mac n Cheese...seriously? we need to explain? $5.29Kids SidesFrench fries
mashed potatoes
sticky rice
broccolini
fresh fruit cup
cole slaw
Kids Cast Iron Brownie$5.99Kids Oreo Snowball$4.99Kids Trip to Disneyland...priceless
-
Baja Fish Tacostacocat spelled backwards is tacocat.
blackened mahi, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime cream $14.99Fish 'n Chipsnot just for Fridays! plenty of beer-battered cold-water Atlantic cod and French fries $15.99New York Stripbrussels sprouts, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi $20.99Ma, The Meatloaf!French green beans, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi $14.99Soy Glazed Salmonseasoned with a soy glaze, sticky rice and stir fried vegetables $18.99Chicken Parmyou taste so good! panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles $15.99
Served with kettle chips, cole slaw or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.49
-
Beer Cheesepanko onion rings, mayo, pickle, LTO $12.49Green Chilipickled chilis, beer cheese, mayo, pickle, LTO $12.49BucketAmerican cheese, MR. PLOT $11.99The Imposterplant-based patty, American cheese, MR.PLOT
make it vegan and dump the dairy (request no mayo or cheese) $12.99TurkeyAmerican cheese, mayo, pickle, LTO $11.79Baconbacon-infused, cheddar, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli $13.79
Served with kettle chips, cole slaw or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.49
-
Buffalo Chicken Sandwichpanko-crusted, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato, mayo $12.49Chicken Finger BLTpilsner-battered, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo $11.79El Cubanotavern ham, braised pork, house mustard, pickles $13.49Hoosier Daddy Pork Tenderloinan Indiana classic!
breaded and fried, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, side mayo $11.99Reubenslow-braised corned beef brisket, swiss, thousand, kraut, artisan rye $13.29Cheesesteakpeppers, onion, mushroom, provolone, Philly sauce $12.49Clubturkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat $11.99Codwichpanko-crusted, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, tartar $11.99
-
Vegan Fried Rice Bowlcauliflower rice, peppers, kimchi, corn, bean sprouts, carrots, broccolini, soy
rebel against the establishment, add sunny-side up egg * $13.99Chicky Chicky Bowlherbed chicken, kale, farro, pickled carrots, curried cauliflower, marinated tomato & beets, pine nuts, goat cheese $15.99Cincinnati 3-Wayspaghetti, chili, cheddar, onion, tomato, sour cream, scallion $14.79Baked Rigatonicrushed meatballs, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil $15.49Beef Stroganoffpot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream $14.49
We've been rolling them by hand since college
-
Margheritaroasted tomato, garlic, fresh mozzarella, basil $13.49Pepperoni and Peppersezzo pepperoni & Hungarian peppers, das it $13.79Veggiespinach, wild mushroom, roasted tomato, peppers, onion, green olive $12.79Wild Mushroomroasted garlic, shiitake, portabella, caramelized onion, spinach, truffle oil $14.99Sicilianitalian sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, tavern ham, peppers, caramelized onion $14.79Cheeseprovolone, whole milk mozzarella $12.29ToppingsMeat: Ezzo pepperoni, sausage, chicken, bacon, tavern ham - $1.75
Veg: jalapeño, peppers, spinach, roasted tomato, onion, wild mushroom, green olive - $1.45
-
Sidekicksbroccolini 3.89
sweet potato fries 3.89
mashed potatoes 3.89
fruit cup 3.89
onion rings 3.89
mac & cheese 4.99
beans & rice 3.89
cole slaw 3.89
-
Sticky Bun Bread Puddingbaked croissants and vanilla custard, caramel, pecans, Edy’s vanilla bean ice cream $6.29New York Cheesecakemacerated strawberry, whipped cream
and bonus, it’s gluten-free friendly! $6.99S'mores BruleeEVERYBODY, EVERYBODY GET YO S’MORES ON, WHAT?
chocolate custard, toasted graham cracker,
brulee’d marshmallow fluff $5.99Dessert Featureask your server about our featured selection created by our chef team!!!NEW!Cast Iron Brownievanilla bean ice cream, caramel, powdered sugar $5.99
Get Brunched in the Face
Saturday & Sunday | 11am-3pm
-
Chicken and Wafflesno description needed $11.79Donut Holescinnamon sugar, cararmel $3.99Breakfast Burritoflour tortilla stuffed with scrambled eggs, sausage, sautéed peppers & onions, pepper jack & cheddar cheese. topped with ranchero sauce, sour cream and cilantro.
served with red skin breakfast potatoes $12.394 Egg Omeletfresh fruit, wheat toast $11.49Short Rib Hashcrispy potatoes, peppers, caramelized onion, sharp cheddar, sunny side eggs $12.99
-
Lemonade or Iced Teacraft your own.
add smashed blueberries, blackberries, raspberry or strawberry puree $3.99Strawberry Cooler$3.99Housemade Cold Brew Coffee$3.99San Pellegrino$3.19IBC Rootbeer$3.19
-
Daily Drink FeaturesMore Pour Monday
get a 20oz draft beer for a 16oz price!
Poppin’ bottles Tuesday
1/2 priced bottles of wine
Whiskey Wednesday
Woodford, Old Forester, Jack & the others
Punch Perfect Thursday
our house draft punch: I’m with friends pitcher or I’m solo
Shaken not stirred Friday
Belvedere martini, pine fin cosmo, pine fin martini
Gary’s Famous Margarita Saturday
share a pitcher (or drink one yourself)
Bloody Sunday
pepper-infused Finlandia Vodka, house-spiced pickle
-
Bourbon and ChillWoodford Reserve Gary’s Blend Private Selection, St. Germain, chamomile simple syrup, fresh lemon, mint $10.00Mustache You A QuestionOld Forester Bucket Private Selection, Sweet Vermouth, Amaro, smoked cinnamon bitters $10.00Pink Gin FizzWatershed, lemon juice, simple syrup, soda, pinot noir float $8.75Blueberry BellaSmirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice $7.75Pine Finyour choice: rocks, martini or cosmo $8.25Draft MargaritaEl Jimador, Cointreau, fresh lemon and lime $8.75 add a bucket of Herradura, El Jimador, or Grand Marnier for 5Draft Bucket PunchMount Gay Rum, pine fin, Cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum $8.75Gin & JuiceLaid back...traditional gin gimlet served up. Watershed Four Peel, lime juice, simple syrup $9.00Bloody Marypepper-soaked Finlandia Vodka
Not Spicy - green, red and Hungarian pepper
Spicy - jalapeno pepper and lime
Stupid Spicy - habanero, green and red pepper $8.75Sangriaginger citrus white or orange pomegranate red $6.75
-
Brown Bag Special12oz $2.50Bell's Two Hearted IPAComstock, MI $5.99Brewdog Elvis JuiceColumbus, OH $5.79Brew Dog Hazy Jane$5.79BudweiserSt Louis, MO $3.99Bud LightSt Louis, MO $3.99CBC BodhiColumbus, OH 46.49Coors LiteDenver, CO $3.99CoronaMexico city, Mexico $5.79Dos XX$4.99Downeast Cider$5.99Fat TireFort Collins, CO $5.79Michelob Ultra$4.29Miller LiteMilwaukee, WI $3.99North High Honey Wheat$5.79Rhinegeist TruthCincinnati, OH $5.79Seventh Son SelectionColumbus, OH $5.99White ClawChicago, IL $5.79
-
Bud LightSt Louis, MO 16oz $4.49 | 20oz $5.49 | 90oz $21.99 | 120oz $27.99Miller LiteMilwaukee, WI 16oz $4.49 | 20oz $5.49 | 90oz $21.99 | 120oz $27.99Blue MoonGolden, CO 16oz $5.99 | 20oz $6.99 | 90oz $28.99 | 120oz $38.99Sam Adams SelectionBoston, MA 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99New Belgium SelectionFort Collins, CO 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99North High Rusty Bucket Jeffrey Pilsner16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99Rhinegeist SelectionCincinnati, OH 16oz $6.79 | 20oz $7.79 | 90oz $31.79 | 120oz $41.79GuinnessDublin, Ireland 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99Stella ArtoisLeuven, Belgium 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
Because...The Catalina Wine Mixer
-
Moscato, Seven Daughters6oz $8.75 | 9oz $11.25 | Bottle $35.00White Zinfandel, Beringer6oz $6.25 | 9oz $8.25 | Bottle $25.00Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00Pinot Grigio, Campanile6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00Sauvignon Blanc, Honig6oz $9.25 | 9oz $11.75 | Bottle $37.00Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”6oz $8.25 | 9oz $10.75 | Bottle $33.00Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”6oz $11.50 | 9oz $14.75 | Bottle $46.00Chardonnay, Trefethen*available by the bottle only $60.00
-
Pinot Noir, Hangtime6oz $9.75 | 9oz $12.75 | Bottle $39.00Cabernet Sauvignon, Glass Mountain6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios6oz $10.25 | 9oz $13.75 | Bottle $41.00Merlot, Benziger6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00Merlot, Red Diamond Winery6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.50 | Bottle $27.00Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”6oz $8.75 | 9oz $11.25 | Bottle $35.00Cabernet Sauvignon, Spellbound6oz $9.75 | 9oz $12.75 | Bottle $39.00Red Blend, The Federalist6oz $13.00 | 9oz $17.00 | Bottle $52.00
-
ProseccoBrut, Zonin, “Special Cuvee” 6oz $9.25 | 9oz $11.75 | Bottle $37.00RoséM. Chapoutier, “Belleruche” 6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00
Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your group has a food allergy or special dietary need (e.g. gluten intolerance). While we will do our best to accommodate your needs, please be aware our restaurant uses ingredients that contain all the major FDA allergens (peanuts, tree nuts, eggs, fish, shellfish, milk, soy & wheat). We offer gluten-free friendly menus; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free.
-
Gluten Free Double Stacked Quesadillablackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean, corn salsa & corn tortilla $11.99Gluten Free Peel & Eat Shrimpchilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce $11.49Gluten Free Double Nickel Saladbacon, tomato, onion, house dressing $6.79NEW!Gluten Free Blackened Salmonshaved fennel and brussels sprouts, kale, greens,strawberry, avocado, shishito pepper, pistachio, goat cheese vinaigrette $15.29Gluten Free Baja Fish Tacosblackened fish, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime cream, corn tortilla $14.79Gluten Free New York Stripmashed potatoes, wild mushroom, french green beans $20.99Gluten Free Pan Seared Salmongarlic and herb glazed, mashed potatoes, green beans $18.99Gluten Free Chicky Chicky Bowlherbed chicken, kale, pickled carrots, curried cauliflower, pine nuts, goat cheese, marinated tomato & beets $15.99Gluten Free Baked Pennegluten-free penne, Italian sausage, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil $15.49Gluten Free Bucket BurgerAmerican cheese, MR. PLOT $11.99Gluten Free Turkey BurgerAmerican cheese, mayo, pickle LTO $11.79Gluten Free Bacon Burgerbacon-infused, cheddar, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli $13.79Gluten Free SidekicksBroccolini - $3.89
Mashed Potatoes - $3.89
Cole Slaw - $3.89
French Green Beans - $3.89
Fruit Cup - $3.89
-
Double Stacked Quesadillablackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa $57.99, Serves 8-10Peel & Eat Shrimpchilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce $57.99, Serves 8-10Brussels Sproutsparmesan, lemon aioli $44.99, Serves 8-10Wingssauces: Joe’s regular, BBQ or habanero. Served with celery & blue cheese $61.99, Serves 8-10Sliderscarmelized onion, American cheese, pickle
$52.99, Serves 8-10Spinach Con Quesoliquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips $42.99, Serves 8-10NEW!Simple Saladcarrot, cucumber, tomato, sharp cheddar, crouton, choice of dressing $29.99 | add chicken $62.99, Serves 6-8Double Nickel Saladmixed greens topped with our special dressing, chopped bacon, blue cheese crumbles, tomatoes and red onion $29.99 | add chicken $62.99, Serves 6-8BBQ Chopped SaladBBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa,tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch
$62.99, Serves 6-8NEW!Greek Saladmixed greens, cured vegetables, pickled onion, marinated tomato, kalamata olive, pepperoncini, chick pea, feta, greek vinaigrette $36.99 | add chicken $69.99, Serves 6-8Baked Rigatonicrushed meatballs, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil $67.99, Serves 6-8Chicken Parmyou taste so good! panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles $67.99, Serves 6-8Beef Stroganoffpot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream $67.99, Serves 6-8Clubturkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat $51.99, Serves 8-10Catering SidesCole Slaw - $24.99
Fruit Salad- $32.99
Broccolini - $29.99
Pasta Salad - $29.99
Mashed Potatoes - $26.99
French Green Beans - $29.99
Kettle Chips - $10.99
Mac & Cheese - $29.99
Serves 8-10
-
Bourbon and ChillWoodford Reserve Gary’s Blend Private Selection, St. Germain, chamomile simple syrup, fresh lemon, mint $10.00Mustache You A QuestionOld Forester Bucket Private Selection, Sweet Vermouth, Amaro, smoked cinnamon bitters $10.00Pink Gin FizzWatershed, lemon juice, simple syrup, soda, pinot noir float $8.75Blueberry BellaSmirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice $7.75Pine Finyour choice: rocks, martini or cosmo $8.25Draft MargaritaEl Jimador, Cointreau, fresh lemon and lime $8.75 add a bucket of Herradura, El Jimador, or Grand Marnier for 5Draft Bucket PunchMount Gay Rum, pine fin, Cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum $8.75Gin & JuiceLaid back...traditional gin gimlet served up. Watershed Four Peel, lime juice, simple syrup $9.00Bloody Marypepper-soaked Finlandia Vodka
Not Spicy - green, red and Hungarian pepper
Spicy - jalapeno pepper and lime
Stupid Spicy - habanero, green and red pepper $8.75Sangriaginger citrus white or orange pomegranate red $6.75
-
Bud LightSt Louis, MO $9.00Coors LiteDenver, CO $9.00Miller LiteMilwaukee, WI $9.00Brewdog Elvis JuiceColumbus, OH $11.00CBC BodhiColumbus, OH $13.00North High Honey Wheat$11.00Rhinegeist TruthCincinnati, OH $11.00Seventh Son Humulus NimbusColumbus, OH $11.00White ClawChicago, IL $10.00
-
Moscato, Seven Daughters$16.00White Zinfandel, Beringer$11.00Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle$12.00Pinot Grigio, Campanile$12.00Sauvignon Blanc, Honig$19.00Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek$11.00Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”$11.00Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”$27.00ProseccoBrut, Zonin, “Special Cuvee” $21.00RoséM. Chapoutier, “Belleruche” $19.00
-
Pinot Noir, Hangtime$14.00Cabernet Sauvignon, Glass Mountain$13.00Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios$17.00Merlot, Benziger$24.00Merlot, Red Diamond Winery$11.00Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”$14.00Cabernet Sauvignon, Spellbound$18.00
* Consuming raw or undercooked meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Please inform your server of any food allergies.
** We offer gluten-free friendly options; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free
