Dayton Menu

Monday — Saturday 11 a.m. — 8:30 p.m.
Sunday: 11 a.m. — 8 p.m.

Menu pricing and items subject to change

 

Make Reservation or
Gary's Favorites

  • Double Stacked Quesadilla
    blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa - $11.49
    Rusty Bucket Wings
    Joe’s Regular, BBQ or Habanero, blue cheese, celery - $12.79
    Spinach Con Queso
    liquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips - $9.99
    Fried Pickles
    pilsner-battered spears, cilantro ranch - $9.29
    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    chilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce - $11.99
    Chicken Fingers
    pilsner-battered, crispy fries - $11.99
    Cheese Blanket Nachos
    please take comfort in the fact that we lose money every time we sell one of these!

    *available for dine-in only - $13.49

  • Crock of Soup
    sirloin chili | french onion | soup du jour  - $6.29
    Duo
    choice of side salad & cup of soup - $10.99
    Trio
    choice of side salad, cup of soup & ½ club sandwich - $12.99
    Double Nickel Salad
    mixed greens topped with our special dressing, bacon, tomato, onion, blue cheese crumbles, house dressing - $6.79 | add chicken 6 or salmon 8
    BBQ Chopped
    BBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa, tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch  - $12.79

Just for Kiddos (10 & Under)
Includes one side and choice of drink

  • Kids Chicken Fingers
    ...BBQ or honey mustard  -$5.99
    Kids Mac n Cheese
    ...seriously? we need to explain?  -$5.29
    Kids Sides
    French fries
    mashed potatoes
    sticky rice
    broccolini
    fresh fruit cup
    cole slaw
      -$5.29
    Kids Trip to Disneyland
    ...priceless

  • Baja Fish Tacos
    tacocat spelled backwards is tacocat.
    blackened fIsh, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime cream - $14.89
    Fish 'n Chips
    not just for Fridays! plenty of beer-battered cold-water Atlantic cod and French fries - $15.49
    New York Strip
    brussels sprouts, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi - $20.99
    Ma, The Meatloaf!
    French green beans, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi - $14.49
    Soy Glazed Salmon
    seasoned with a soy glaze, sticky rice and stir fried vegetables  - $19.49
    Chicken Parm
    you taste so good! panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles - $15.49

Served with kettle chips, cole slaw or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.49

  • Beer Cheese
    panko onion rings, mayo, pickle, LTO - $11.99
    Green Chili
    pickled chilis, beer cheese, mayo, pickle, LTO - $11.99
    Bucket
    American cheese, MR. PLOT - $11.99
    Turkey
    American cheese, mayo, pickle, LTO - $11.49
    Bacon
    bacon-infused, cheddar, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli - $12.99

Served with kettle chips, cole slaw or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.49

  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
    panko-crusted, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato, mayo - $12.49
    Chicken Finger BLT
    pilsner-battered, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo - $11.79
    Hoosier Daddy Pork Tenderloin
    an Indiana classic!

    breaded and fried, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, side mayo - $11.99
    Reuben
    slow-braised corned beef brisket, swiss, thousand, kraut, artisan rye - $13.29
    Cheesesteak
    peppers, onion, mushroom, provolone, Philly sauce - $12.79
    Club
    turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat - $11.99
    Codwich
    panko-crusted, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, tartar - $11.99

  • Cincinnati 3-Way
    spaghetti, chili, cheddar, onion, tomato, sour cream, scallion - $14.79
    Beef Stroganoff
    pot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream - $14.29

We've been rolling them by hand since college

  • Margherita
    roasted tomato, garlic, fresh mozzarella, basil - $12.99
    Pepperoni and Peppers
    ezzo pepperoni & Hungarian peppers, das it - $12.99
    Veggie
    spinach, wild mushroom, roasted tomato, peppers, onion, green olive - $12.79
    Sicilian
    italian sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, tavern ham, peppers, caramelized onion - $14.79
    Cheese
    provolone, whole milk mozzarella - $11.99
    Toppings
    Meat: Ezzo pepperoni, sausage, chicken, bacon, tavern ham - $1.75

    Veg: jalapeño, peppers, spinach, roasted tomato, onion, wild mushroom, green olive ​- $1.45

  • Sidekicks
    broccolini 3.89
    sweet potato fries 3.89
    mashed potatoes 3.89
    fruit cup 3.89
    onion rings 3.89
    mac & cheese 4.99
    beans & rice 3.89
    cole slaw 3.89

  • Sticky Bun Bread Pudding
    baked croissants and vanilla custard, caramel, pecans, Edy’s vanilla bean ice cream -$6.99
    New York Cheesecake
    macerated strawberry, whipped cream
    and bonus, it’s gluten-free friendly! -$6.29
    S'mores Brulee
    EVERYBODY, EVERYBODY GET YO S’MORES ON, WHAT?
    chocolate custard, toasted graham cracker,
    brulee’d marshmallow fluff - $5.99
    Dessert Feature
    Check with your server to see what our Chefs got cooking in their Easy Bake Oven.

  • Lemonade or Iced Tea
    craft your own.

    add smashed blueberries, blackberries, raspberry or strawberry puree - $3.99
    Strawberry Cooler
    - $3.99
    Housemade Cold Brew Coffee
    - $3.99
    San Pellegrino
    - $3.49
    IBC Rootbeer
    - $3.19

  • More Pour Monday
    get a 20oz draft beer for a 16oz price!
    Poppin' Bottles Tuesday
    1/2 priced bottles of wine 
    Whiskey Wednesday
    Woodford, Old Forester, Jack & the others
    Punch Perfect Thursday
    our house draft punch: I’m with friends pitcher or I’m solo
    Shaken Not Stirred Friday
    Belvedere martini, pine fin cosmo, pine fin martini
    Gary's Famous Margarita Saturday
    share a pitcher (or drink one yourself)
    Sunday - Bloody Sunday
    Pepper infused Finlandia Vodka, House Spiced Pickle, Not spicy, Spicy, or Stupid Spicy

  • Bourbon and Chill
    Woodford Reserve Gary’s Blend Private Selection, St. Germain, chamomile simple syrup, fresh lemon, mint -$10.00
    Mustache You A Question
    Old Forester Bucket Private Selection, Sweet Vermouth, Amaro, smoked cinnamon bitters -$10.00
    Pink Gin Fizz
    Watershed, lemon juice, simple syrup, soda, pinot noir float -$8.75
    Blueberry Bella
    Smirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice -$7.50
    Pine Fin
    your choice: rocks, martini or cosmo -$8.00
    Sangria
    ginger citrus white or orange pomegranate red -$6.75
    Draft Margarita
    El Jimador, Cointreau, fresh lemon and lime -$8.50 add a bucket of Herradura, El Jimador, or Grand Marnier for 5
    Draft Bucket Punch
    Mount Gay Rum, pine fin, Cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum -$8.75
    Gin & Juice
    Laid back...traditional gin gimlet served up. Watershed Four Peel, lime juice, simple syrup -$9.00
    Bloody Mary
    pepper-soaked Finlandia Vodka

    Not Spicy - green, red and Hungarian pepper
    Spicy - jalapeno pepper and lime
    Stupid Spicy - habanero, green and red pepper -$8.50

  • Brown Bag Special
    12oz $2.50
    Bell's Two Hearted IPA
    Comstock, MI $5.99
    Breckenridge Vanilla Porter
    Breckenridge, CO - $5.49
    Bud Light
    St Louis, MO $3.99
    Budweiser
    St Louis, MO $3.99
    Coors Lite
    Denver, CO $3.99
    Corona
    Mexico city, Mexico $5.49
    Heineken
    Amsterdam, Netherlands $5.49
    Madtree Seasonal
    $5.49
    Michelob Ultra
    St Louis, MO $4.29
    Miller Lite
    Milwaukee, WI $3.99
    Rhinegeist
    $5.99
    Troeg's Dreamweaver
    Hershey, PA - $5.49
    Warped Wing Trotwood
    $5.49
    Yellow Springs Boat Show
    $5.49
    Yuengling Lager
    Pottsville, Pa $4.29
    White Claw
    Chicago, IL $5.49

  • Bud Light
    St Louis, MO 16oz $4.29 | 20oz $5.29 | 90oz $21.49 | 120oz $26.99
    Miller Lite
    Milwaukee, WI 16oz $4.29 | 20oz $5.29 | 90oz $21.49 | 120oz $26.99
    Blue Moon
    Golden, CO 16oz $5.99 | 20oz $6.99 | 90oz $28.99 | 120oz $38.99
    Sam Adams Selection
    Boston, MA 16oz $6.29 | 20oz $7.29 | 90oz $29.99 | 120oz $39.99
    Angry Orchard
    Walden, NY 16oz $6.29 | 20oz $7.29 | 90oz $29.99 | 120oz $39.99
    New Belgium Selection
    Fort Collins, CO 16oz $6.29 | 20oz $7.29 | 90oz $29.99 | 120oz $39.99
    Fat Tire
    Fort Collins, CO 16oz $6.29 | 20oz $7.29 | 90oz $29.99 | 120oz $39.99
    Lock 27 Selection
    Dayton, OH 16oz $6.29 | 20oz $7.29 | 90oz $29.99 | 120oz $39.99
    North High Selection
    Columbus, OH 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    Brewdog Selection
    Columbus, OH 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    North High Rusty Bucket Jeffrey Pilsner
    16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    Guinness
    Dublin, Ireland 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    Stella Artois
    Leuven, Belgium 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    Kentucky Bourbon Barrel
    16oz $9.99
    Bell's Selection
    Kalamazoo, MI 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    Rhinegeist Selection
    Cincinnati, OH 16oz $6.49 | 20oz $7.49 | 90oz $30.99 | 120oz $40.99
    Fat Head Selection
    Middleburg Heights, OH 16oz $5.99 | 20oz $6.99 | 90oz $28.99 | 120oz $38.99
    Yellow Springs Zoetic Pale Ale
    16oz $6.29 | 20oz $7.29 | 90oz $29.99 | 120oz $39.99

Because...The Catalina Wine Mixer

  • Moscato, Seven Daughters
    6oz $8.50 | 9oz $11.00 | Bottle $34.00
    White Zinfandel, Beringer
    6oz $6.00 | 9oz $8.00 | Bottle $24.00
    Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.25 | Bottle $27.00
    Pinot Grigio, Campanile
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.25 | Bottle $27.00
    Sauvignon Blanc, Honig
    6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00
    Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.25 | Bottle $27.00
    Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”
    6oz $8.25 | 9oz $10.75 | Bottle $33.00
    Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”
    6oz $11.50 | 9oz $14.75 | Bottle $46.00
    Chardonnay, Trefethen
    *available by the bottle only $60.00

  • Pinot Noir, Hangtime
    6oz $9.75 | 9oz $12.75 | Bottle $39.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Glass Mountain
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.25 | Bottle $27.00
    Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios
    6oz $10.25 | 9oz $13.75 | Bottle $41.00
    Merlot, Benziger
    6oz $9.00 | 9oz $11.50 | Bottle $36.00
    Merlot, Red Diamond Winery
    6oz $6.75 | 9oz $9.25 | Bottle $27.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”
    6oz $8.75 | 9oz $11.25 | Bottle $35.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Spellbound
    6oz $9.75 | 9oz $12.75 | Bottle $39.00
    Red Blend, The Federalist
    6oz $13.00 | 9oz $17.00 | Bottle $52.00

  • Prosecco
    Brut, Zonin, “Special Cuvee” 6oz $9.25 | 9oz $11.75 | Bottle $37.00
    Rosé
    M. Chapoutier, “Belleruche” 6oz $8.75 | 9oz $11.25 | Bottle $35.00

  • Gluten Free Double Stacked Quesadilla
    blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean, corn salsa & corn tortilla - $11.29
    Gluten Free Peel & Eat Shrimp
    chilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce - $11.99
    Gluten Free Double Nickel Salad
    bacon, tomato, onion, house dressing - $6.79
    Gluten Free Baja Fish Tacos
    blackened fish, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime cream, corn tortilla - $14.99
    Gluten Free New York Strip
    mashed potatoes, wild mushroom, french green beans - $20.99
    Gluten Free Pan Seared Salmon
    garlic and herb glazed, mashed potatoes, green beans - $19.49
    Gluten Free Chicky Chicky Bowl
    herbed chicken, kale, pickled carrots, curried cauliflower, pine nuts, goat cheese, marinated tomato & beets - $15.99
    Gluten Free Baked Penne
    gluten-free penne, Italian sausage, tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, mozzarella, basil - $15.79
    Gluten Free Bucket Burger
    American cheese, MR. PLOT - $11.99
    Gluten Free Turkey Burger
    American cheese, mayo, pickle LTO - $11.49
    Gluten Free Bacon Burger
    bacon-infused, cheddar, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli - $12.99
    Gluten Free Sidekicks
    Broccolini - $3.89
    Mashed Potatoes - $3.89
    Cole Slaw - $3.89
    French Green Beans - $3.89
    Fruit Cup - $3.89
    Gluten Free New York Cheesecake
    macerated strawberry, whipped cream - $6.99

Make it a double $5

  • Blueberry Bella
    Smirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice - $7.50
    Pine Fin
    your choice: rocks, martini or cosmo - $8.00
    Draft Margarita
    El Jimador, Cointreau, fresh lemon and lime - $8.50
    Draft Bucket Punch
    Mount Gay Rum, pine fin, Cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum - $8.75
    Bloody Mary
    pepper-soaked Finlandia Vodka

    Not Spicy - green, red and Hungarian pepper
    Spicy - jalapeno pepper and lime
    Stupid Spicy - habanero, green and red pepper - $8.50

  • Miller Lite
    Milwaukee, WI - $9.00
    Coors Lite
    Denver, CO - $9.00
    Bud Light
    St Louis, MO - $9.00
    White Claw
    Chicago, IL - $10.00
    Bell's Two Hearted IPA
    Comstock, MI - $11.00
    Breckenridge Vanilla Porter
    Breckenridge, CO - $10.00
    Rhinegeist Truth
    Cincinnati, OH - $11.00
    Madtree Psychopathy
    CINCINNATI, OH - $11.00
    Yellow Springs Boat Show
    - $10.00
    Troeg's Dreamweaver
    Hershey, PA - $10.00

Because... the Catalina Wine Mixer

  • Moscato, Seven Daughters
    - $16.00
    White Zinfandel, Beringer
    - $11.00
    Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle
    - $12.00
    Pinot Grigio, Campanile
    - $12.00
    Sauvignon Blanc, Honig
    - $19.00
    Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek
    - $11.00
    Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”
    - $11.00
    Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”
    - $27.00
    Prosecco
    Brut, Zonin, “Special Cuvee” - $21.00
    Rosé
    M. Chapoutier, “Belleruche” - $19.00

  • Pinot Noir, Hangtime
    - $14.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Glass Mountain
    - $13.00
    Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios
    - $17.00
    Merlot, Benziger
    - $24.00
    Merlot, Red Diamond Winery
    - $11.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”
    - $14.00
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Spellbound
    - $18.00

  • Double Stacked Quesadilla
    blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa - $57.99, Serves 8-10
    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    chilled, Old Bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce - $57.99, Serves 8-10
    Wings
    sauces: Joe’s regular, BBQ or habanero. Served with celery & blue cheese  - $61.99, Serves 8-10
    Sliders
    carmelized onion, American cheese, pickle
      - $52.99, Serves 8-10
    Spinach Con Queso
    liquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips - $42.99, Serves 8-10
    Double Nickel Salad
    mixed greens topped with our special dressing, chopped bacon, blue cheese crumbles, tomatoes and red onion - $29.99 | add chicken $62.99, Serves 6-8
    BBQ Chopped Salad
    BBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa,tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch 
      - $62.99, Serves 6-8
    Chicken Parm
    you taste so good! panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles - $67.99, Serves 6-8
    Beef Stroganoff
    pot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream - $67.99, Serves 6-8
    Club
    turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat - $51.99, Serves 8-10
    Catering Sides
    Cole Slaw - $24.99
    Fruit Salad- $32.99
    Broccolini - $29.99
    Pasta Salad - $29.99
    Mashed Potatoes - $26.99
    French Green Beans - $29.99
    Kettle Chips - $10.99
    Mac & Cheese - $29.99

      Serves 8-10

* Consuming raw or undercooked meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Please inform your server of any food allergies.

** We offer gluten-free friendly options; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free