Now hiring shiny, Rusty people. Great pay, sweet perks, safe environment. Apply Now!

Bexley Menu

Monday - Thursday: 11 a.m. - 10 p.m. 
Friday - Saturday: 11 a.m. - 11 p.m.
Sunday: 11a.m. - 9 p.m.

Menu pricing and items subject to change

 

Gary's Favorites

To take the edge off...or make the kids happy

  • Salted Edamame
    BBQ Pork Rinds
    Slider

  • Pierogi
    Double Stacked Quesadilla
    Wings
    Spinach Con Queso
    Fried Pickles
    Brussels Sprouts
    Buffalo Cauliflower
    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    Chicken Fingers
    Cheese Blanket Nachos

  • Crock of Soup
    Duo
    Trio
    Double Nickel Salad
    Simple
    Greek
    Blackened Salmon
    Cobb
    BBQ Chopped

Just for kiddos (10 & Under)
Includes one side & choice of drink

  • Kids Sliders
    Kids Soft Tacos
    Kids French Bread Pizza
    Kids Fish n Chips
    Kids Chicken Fingers
    Kids Spaghetti & Meatball
    Kids Mac n Cheese
    Kids Cast Iron Brownie
    Kids Oreo Snowball
    Kids Trip to Disneyland

  • Baja Tacos
    Fish & Chips
    New York Strip
    Ma, The Meatloaf!
    Soy Glazed Salmon
    Chicken Parm

Served with kettle chips, cole slaw or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.59
100% whole wheat bun available upon request

  • Bucket
    The Imposter
    Turkey
    Bacon

Sandwiches served with your choice of kettle chips, cole slaw or fries
Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.59
100% whole wheat bun available upon request

  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
    El Cubano
    Hoosier Daddy Pork Tenderloin
    Reuben
    Cheesesteak
    Club Sandwich
    Codwich

  • Vegan Fried Rice Bowl
    Chicky Chicky Bowl
    Baked Rigatoni
    Beef Stroganoff

We've been rolling them by hand since college

  • Margherita
    Pepperoni & Peppers
    Veggie
    Wild Mushroom
    Sicilian
    Cheese
    Toppings

  • Sidekicks

  • Sticky Bun Bread Pudding
    New York Cheesecake
    Cast Iron Brownie
    Dessert Feature

Brunch without booze is just a sad, late breakfast
Saturday & Sunday | 11am-3pm

  • Chicken and Waffles
    Breakfast Burrito
    Short Rib Hash

  • Lemonade or Iced Tea
    Strawberry Cooler
    Housemade Fresh Cold Brew Coffee
    San Pellegrino

  • Daily Drink Features

If you are drinking to forget, please pay in advance

  • Blueberry Bella
    Pine Fin
    Sangria
    Draft Margarita
    Draft Bucket Punch
    Bloody Mary

  • Brown Bag Special
    Bell's Two Hearted IPA
    Brewdog Elvis Juice
    Budweiser
    Bud Light
    CBC Bodhi
    Coors Light
    Corona
    Fat Tire
    Heineken
    Michelob Ultra
    Miller Lite
    North High Honey Wheat
    Rhinegeist Cans
    Seventh Son Humulus Nimbus
    Strongbow CIDER
    Truly
    Yuengling Lager
    White Claw

If you see the glass as half full, it’s time for another beer

  • Bud Light
    Miller Lite
    Blue Moon
    Sam Adams Selection
    New Belgium Selection
    North High Rusty Bucket Jeffrey Pilsner
    Brewdog Selection
    Guinness
    Stella Artois

Because...The Catalina Wine Mixer

  • White Zinfandel, Beringer
    Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle
    Pinot Grigio, Campanile
    Sauvignon Blanc, Honig
    Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek
    Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”
    Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”

Age and glasses of wine should never be counted

  • Pinot Noir, Hangtime
    Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios
    Merlot, Benziger
    Merlot, Red Diamond Winery
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”
    Red Blend, The Federalist

  • Prosecco
    Rosé

Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your group has a food allergy or special dietary need (e.g. gluten intolerance). While we will do our best to accommodate your needs, please be aware our restaurant uses ingredients that contain all the major FDA allergens (peanuts, tree nuts, eggs, fish, shellfish, milk, soy & wheat). We offer gluten-free friendly menus; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free.

  • Gluten Free Double Stacked Quesadilla
    Gluten Free Peel & Eat Shrimp
    Gluten Free Double Nickel Salad
    Gluten Free Baja Tacos
    Gluten Free New York Strip
    Gluten Free Pan Seared Salmon
    Gluten Free Chicky Chicky Bowl
    Gluten Free Baked Penne
    Gluten Free Bucket Burger
    Gluten Free Turkey Burger
    Gluten Free Bacon Burger
    Gluten Free Sidekicks
    Gluten Free New York Cheesecake

  • Double Stacked Quesadilla
    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    Brussels Sprouts
    Wings
    Sliders
    Spinach Con Queso
    Simple Salad
    Double Nickel Salad
    BBQ Chopped Salad
    Greek Salad
    Baked Rigatoni
    Chicken Parm
    Beef Stroganoff
    Club Sandwich
    Catering Sides

If you are drinking to forget, please pay in advance
Make it a double $5

  • Blueberry Bella
    Pine Fin
    Draft Margarita
    Draft Bucket Punch
    Bloody Mary
    Sangria

  • Bud Light
    Coors Light
    Miller Lite
    Brewdog Elvis Juice
    CBC Bodhi
    North High Honey Wheat
    Rhinegeist Truth
    Seventh Son Humulus Nimbus
    White Claw

Because...the Catalina Wine Mixer

  • White Zinfandel, Beringer
    Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle
    Pinot Grigio, Campanile
    Sauvignon Blanc, Honig
    Chardonnay, Jacob's Creek
    Chardonnay, Unoaked Columbia Crest, “Grand Estates”
    Chardonnay, Sonoma Cutrer “Russian River Ranches”
    Prosecco
    Rosé

Age and glasses of wine should never be counted

  • Pinot Noir, Hangtime
    Malbec, Susana Balbo, Crios
    Merlot, Benziger
    Merlot, Red Diamond Winery
    Cabernet Sauvignon, Beringer, “Founder’s Estate”

* Consuming raw or undercooked meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Please inform your server of any food allergies.

** We offer gluten-free friendly options; however, our kitchen is not completely gluten-free